Cute place with a super cute name. Inwas waiting fir pizza next door. Had 20 min to kill so I walked over to check out this ice cream place. Oh its the perfect country ice cream shop. They serve Johnson's Ice Cream which is made in near by Bexley Ohio. Johnsons has great ice cream if you haven't had it... try it you will love it. I guess here they add googley eyes to the ice cream. I just love that. I didnt get ice cream. I decided to go with a house made cookie. Butterscotch. They're true to their name my cookie was slathered in butterscotch syrup too. So my hands were super sticky! You might want to make sure you have wipes somewhere in the car. (i did). But wow. Great cookie. Wasnt expecting that. Will definitely be back next season. Couldnt find anything wrong. A+

Good place for ice cream. Quaint little building in the state park. Service was nice and priced reasonably

Sticky Fingers is a summer favorite for our family. We love the patio seating and that dogs are welcome! You can't go wrong with a scoop of Buckeye Fever or Salted Carmel Pretzel!

Stopped here after a day on the lake at Alum Creek and it was so good! This was our first time trying Stickyfingers and hope to make it an annual tradition on our annual boat trip with the family!

Stopped here by chance. I tried the strawberry- not a fan. I had a double cone with pistachio and chocolate fudge brownie. I liked that the pistachio had real pistachio nuts in it. The chocolate fudge brownie was awesome, I would say it compares to jenis blackout chocolate cake ice cream but more of a milk chocolate. Service was very nice and I would come back again for the chocolate fudge brownie. My regret was not getting two scoops instead of one!

Freaking delicious! And the edible googly eyes? Come on, 10/10. Any time we're in the area, we will be stopping by this parlor. The flavor variety is large enough to please just about anyone - including your pup! I ordered the lemon sorbet and it tasted like a glass of fresh lemonade. Amazing. I stole a spoonful of my boyfriend's strawberry ice cream and it was just as yummy. The prices are good and the staff are just as friendly as they are fast at bringing out your order. The outdoor seating area is small, but big enough to hold a few families. I can't wait to go back and try another flavor!

Such a cute ice cream place with covered and uncovered outdoor seating where you can sit and enjoy the delicious ice creams. And speaking of ice creams, they have so many flavors with tons of different topping options. From all the flavors that I have tasted, every single one of them was just delicious. But my favorite was the salted caramel chocolate pretzel and red velvet. I like their ice cream sandwiches. I ordered the sandwich with double chocolate chip cookies, you could never have too much chocolate. The customer service was great, very friendly. I'll definitely be coming back here again

Two thumbs way up! The perfect stop on a beautiful end of summer evening. It also made for a very pretty drive around the Alum Creek area. It was super busy as a local Little League team had stopped by for some after-game treats. The staff handled the crowd so well, and it did not take long at all to get our ice cream after we ordered. They have a cute little patio for outdoor seating and a drive-through around the side of the building. For my fellow peanut butter lovers - the Buckeye Fever flavor was amazing! Peanut butter ice cream base with chocolate chips. I had a hot fudge sundae that, although was very light on the hot fudge, just made me so happy. I love how the ice cream here is not too sweet. I think it is the best ice cream I have had in Ohio in fact! Please check out this small business and hope you enjoy as much as I did.

Sticky Fingers ice cream is really good! I enjoyed the ice cream flight. My favorite flavor was a toss up between the birthday cake and blueberry pie. The cookie dough and moose tracks were good as well. The strawberry milk shake was not as thick as my boyfriend would have liked. It was topped with whipped cream and a cherry I honestly believe my beagle enjoyed her ice cream more than we enjoyed ours! She licked the cup clean and wanted more. She didn't enjoy the dog treat as much as the ice cream. We will be back for ice cream cookie sandwiches.

I took a nice summer drive up to Sticky Fingers today. The heat and beautiful water on Alum Creek set the mood as I pulled in to the super cute wrap around porch Sticky Finger calls home! I opted for the flight and the staff were super helpful by offering the most popular flavors of ice cream and I'm so thankful I got to choose four! Within a minute, my order was up. I needed to get home but the little wrap around porch is super cute and would be a great place to hang out and have a yummy treat. The mocha chip was amazing! I scarfed that one down before leaving the driveway. The mint cookies & cream was also very tasty but I wanted to save that for my little guy. The buckeye fever was also delicious and I can see why it's a customer favorite. If you're ever in the area, it's a must stop treat!